WEST virginia legislature
2019 First EXTRAORDINARY session
Senate Bill 1009
By Senators Carmichael (Mr.
President) and Prezioso
(By Request of the Executive)
[Introduced May 20, 2019]
A BILL to amend and reenact §18C-3-3 of the Code of West Virginia, 1931, as amended; and to amend said code by adding thereto a new section, designated §18C-3-5, all relating to establishing health professionals student loan programs; providing legislative findings and purpose; establishing a loan repayment program for mental health providers; providing for in-state tuition rates to out-of-state medical students who agree to practice for a specific time within West Virginia; establishing the program eligibility requirements; setting forth repayment schedules; creating application procedures; establishing violations; providing for civil penalties for the failure to complete the required service; creating special revenue accounts; and providing for specific policy provisions.
Be it enacted by the Legislature of West Virginia:
ARTICLE 3. HEALTH PROFESSIONALS STUDENT LOAN PROGRAMS.
§18C-3-3. Health Sciences Service Program; establishment; administration; eligibility.
findings. — The Legislature finds that there is a critical need for
additional practicing health care professionals in West Virginia. Therefore,
there is created a Health Sciences Service Program to be administered by the
Vice Chancellor for Health Sciences. The purpose of this program is to provide
an incentive for health professional students to complete their training and
provide primary care and emergency medical care in underserved areas of West
Virginia (b) Special account.
–– (a) There is continued a
special revolving fund account under the Higher Education Policy Commission in
the State Treasury formerly known as the Health Sciences Scholarship Fund. and
hereafter designated the Health Sciences Service Program Fund The fund
shall be used to accomplish the purposes of this section. The fund consists of
any of the following:
(1) All unexpended health sciences scholarship funds on deposit in the State Treasury on the effective date of this section;
(2) Appropriations as may be provided by the Legislature;
(3) Repayments, including interest as set by the Vice Chancellor for Health Sciences, collected from program award recipients who fail to practice or teach in West Virginia under the terms of an award agreement or the health sciences scholarship program previously established by this section; and
(4) Amounts that may become available from other sources.
Balances remaining in the fund at the end of the fiscal year do not expire or revert to the general revenue. All costs associated with the administration of this section shall be paid from the Health Sciences Service Program Fund under the direction of the Vice Chancellor for Health Sciences.
requirements. — (b) Award
preference is given to West Virginia residents. An individual is eligible for
consideration for a Health Sciences Service Program award if the individual:
(A) Is a fourth-year medical student at the Marshall University School of Medicine, West Virginia School of Osteopathic Medicine or West Virginia University School of Medicine who has been accepted in a primary care or emergency medicine internship/residency program in West Virginia; or
(B) Is enrolled in an approved education program at a West Virginia institution leading to a degree or certification in the field of nurse practitioner, nurse educator, nurse midwife, physician assistant, dentist, pharmacist, physical therapist, doctoral clinical psychologist, licensed independent clinical social worker or other disciplines identified as shortage fields by the Vice Chancellor for Health Sciences; and
(2) Signs an agreement to practice for at least two years in an underserved area of West Virginia or, if pursuing a Master’s Degree in nursing, signs an agreement to teach at least two years for a school of nursing located in West Virginia, as may be determined by the Vice Chancellor for Health Sciences, after receiving the master’s degree.
(d) Program awards. — (c) Program awards shall be in an amount set
by the Higher Education Policy Commission of at least $20,000 for medical and
dental students and at least $10,000 for all others and may be awarded by the
Vice Chancellor for Health Sciences, with the advice of an advisory panel, from
the pool of all applicants with a commitment to practice in an underserved area
of West Virginia. This section does not grant or guarantee any applicant any
right to a program award. (e) Repayment
provisions. — (d) A
program award recipient who fails to practice in an underserved area of West
Virginia within six months of the completion of his or her training, or who
fails to complete his or her training or required teaching, is in breach of
contract and is liable for repayment of the program award and any accrued
interest. The granting or renewal of a license to practice in West Virginia or
to reciprocal licensure in another state based upon licensure in West Virginia
is contingent upon beginning payment and continuing payment until complete
repayment of the award and any accrued interest. A license, renewal or
reciprocity may not be granted to any person whose repayment is in arrears. The
appropriate regulatory board shall inform all other states where a recipient
has reciprocated based upon West Virginia licensure of any refusal to renew
licensure in West Virginia as a result of failure to repay the award. This
provision shall be explained in bold type in the award contract. Repayment
terms, not inconsistent with this section, shall be established by the Vice
Chancellor for Health Sciences pursuant to the rule required by this section.
(e) (1) There is created a student loan repayment program to be administered by the Higher Education Policy Commission. The loan repayment program shall help repay the student loans for mental health providers who provide therapy and counseling services and who reside in West Virginia and work in an underserved area of West Virginia for up to three years beginning January 1, 2020. Individuals participating in the loan repayment program may be eligible to receive up to $30,000 to be dispersed as follows:
(A) A participant may receive a loan repayment program award of up to $10,000 each year in exchange for the participant completing one year of practice in an underserved area.
(B) A participant may not receive a program award for more than three years of practice.
(C) A participant must direct each award received toward the repayment of his or her educational loans.
(2) There is created a special revenue fund account under the Higher Education Policy Commission in the State Treasury known as the “Mental Health Provider Student Loan Repayment Fund”. The fund shall be used to accomplish the purposes of this subsection. The fund shall consist of appropriations as may be provided by the Legislature. Any moneys remaining in the fund at the close of a fiscal year shall be carried forward for use in the next fiscal year.
(f) Rule. — The Higher Education Policy Commission shall
promulgate a rule pursuant to §29A-3A-1 et seq.
— As used in this section:
(1) “Training” means:
(A) The entire degree program or certification program for nurse midwives, nurse practitioners, nurse educators, physician assistants, dentists, pharmacists, physical therapists, doctoral clinical psychologists, licensed independent clinical social workers and other disciplines identified as shortage fields by the Vice Chancellor for Health Sciences; or
(B) Completion of a degree program and an approved residency/internship program for students pursuing a degree in medicine or osteopathy, or as otherwise may be designated for such students in the rule required by this section.
(2) “Underserved area” means any primary care health professional shortage area located in the state as determined by the Bureau for Public Health or any additional health professional shortage area, including an emergency medicine professional determined by the Vice Chancellor for Health Sciences.
§18C-3-5. Nonresident Medical Student Tuition Regularization Program.
(a) The Legislature finds as follows:
(1) There is a critical need for additional primary care physicians practicing in West Virginia;
(2) West Virginia has an aging population, and an increasing need for recruiting primary care physicians and placing primary care physicians in rural areas of the state;
(3) West Virginia has a historically low retention rate of state resident medical students following graduation;
(4) Efforts by the medical schools in West Virginia to increase class sizes as a means of increasing the number of physicians practicing in the state have been largely ineffective;
(5) The primary care field of practice yields a lower wage than other medical specialties and maintains an extreme shortage of practicing physicians, particularly in rural areas of the state;
(6) The high cost of nonresident medical education tuition, and resulting high level of debt incurred by students, often prohibit nonresident graduates who remain in the state from entering a primary care practice;
(7) Many nonresident medical students in West Virginia have indicated that they would be willing to remain in the state as a practicing physician if it was affordable;
(8) A waiver of the state resident to nonresident tuition rate differential would offset the significant student debt load incurred by nonresident medical school graduates;
(9) Beginning a medical practice with up to four years committed to practicing medicine in a specific area has a strong likelihood of influencing a nonresident medical school graduate to remain in that area following the service commitment;
(10) Investing resources, developing professional networks, and creating community ties all serve to create permanent connections to an area for an individual who is not originally from that area; and
(11) Attracting practicing physicians to rural and medically under-served areas of the state will further attract related health-care professionals that support a medical practice or facility and will expand the economic and job-growth potential of such areas.
(b) It is the purpose of this section to offer nonresident medical students a partial tuition waiver as a means of recruiting practicing physicians to under-served areas, and to primary care and practitioner shortage fields in West Virginia.
(c) There is created the Nonresident Medical Student Tuition Regularization Program to be administered by the Vice Chancellor for Health Sciences in cooperation with the deans of the three medical schools in the state.
(1) Two nonresident medical students from each medical school in the state are selected annually to participate in the program subject to the exception provided in subsection (f) of this section.
(2) Each student selected is charged the state resident tuition rate for each academic year he or she is enrolled in the program, and has the cost differential between the resident and nonresident rates waived by the institution at which he or she is enrolled.
(3) For each academic year that a medical student participates in the program, he or she shall commit to render services for one calendar year as a medical doctor or a doctor of osteopathy in this state in a medically under-served area or in a primary care or specialty practice or field in which there is a shortage of physicians, as determined by the Division of Health at the time the application for the program is submitted. The service commitment begins within six months after graduation from an accredited residency program.
(4) Once selected to participate in the program, a student may continue in the program for as long as he or she continues to meet the eligibility criteria in subsection (d) of this section, for a maximum of four academic years.
(d) An individual is eligible for enrollment or continuation in the program if he or she meets the following criteria:
(1) Is enrolled or accepted for enrollment at the West Virginia University School of Medicine, the Marshall University School of Medicine, or the West Virginia School of Osteopathic Medicine in a program leading to the degree of medical doctor (M.D.) or doctor of osteopathy (D.O.);
(2) Has not yet received one of the degrees provided in subdivision (1) of this subsection;
(3) Satisfies the academic standards established by the program rule;
(4) Is not in default of any previous student loan;
(5) Is a nonresident student who is charged nonresident tuition rates;
(6) Commits to render services for one calendar year as a medical doctor or a doctor of osteopathy in this state in a medically under-served area or in a primary care or specialty practice or field in which there is a shortage of physicians for each academic year for which he or she participates in the program;
(7) Submits to the commission:
(A) An application for enrollment in the program as provided by the commission; and
(B) A sworn statement of commitment to service on a form provided by the commission for that purpose; and
(8) Other criteria as established by the program rule.
(e) (1) A program participant violates the service commitment if he or she:
(A) Fails to render services as a medical doctor or doctor of osteopathy in accordance with the sworn statement he or she submitted to the commission. This includes failure to begin serving within six months of completing an accredited residency program, or failure to complete each one-year term to which he or she committed to serve; or
(B) Fails to complete or remain enrolled in the medical education program for which he or she obtained the tuition waiver.
(2) A program participant who violates the service commitment is subject to the following:
(A) He or she shall repay the amount of nonresident tuition charges waived plus interest at a rate of five percent per annum;
(B) The granting or renewal of a license to practice medicine in West Virginia or to reciprocal licensure in another state based upon licensure in West Virginia is contingent upon commencing payment and continuing payment until full repayment of the obligation if the recipient fails to complete the required practice commitment. A license, renewal or reciprocity may not be granted to an individual whose repayments are in arrears. The West Virginia Board of Medicine shall inform all other states where a recipient has reciprocated based upon West Virginia licensure of any refusal to renew licensure in West Virginia as a result of failure to repay the tuition amount.
(f) The commission shall develop policy to provide for:
(1) A method for selecting annually the six new students to be enrolled in the program, with priority consideration to applicants in the earliest academic years of the medical education program;
(2) A method for selecting greater or fewer than two participants from a single medical school in any year where two suitable applicants are not available at each school;
(3) A method for the applicant to select the service area or specialty to which he or she commits to practice medicine;
(4) A method for developing a mutually agreeable modification to the terms of a participant’s service commitment regarding the medically under-served area or primary care or specialty practice or field in which he or she committed to serve under circumstances where the Division of Health determines at the time the participant’s service commitment is scheduled to commence that the area is no longer medically under-served or that primary care or service specialty is no longer experiencing a physician shortage;
(5) Provisions for enforcing sanctions against a participant who fails to satisfy the service commitment; and
(6) Such other provisions as the commission considers necessary to administer the program.
(g) There is created in the State Treasury a special revenue account to be designated the “Nonresident Medical Student Tuition Regularization Fund” which is an interest-bearing account that may be invested and retain all earnings. Expenditures from the fund shall be for the purposes set forth in this section and are to be made only in accordance with appropriation by the Legislature and in accordance with §11B-2-1 et seq. of this code.
NOTE: The purpose of this bill is to establish health professionals’ student loan programs to encourage mental health service providers and primary care physicians to practice in the state.
Strike-throughs indicate language that would be stricken from a heading or the present law and underscoring indicates new language that would be added.